Challenger Brand Study 2027, Part I: A Look Back to Move Forward

Challenger Brand Study 2027, Part I: A Look Back to Move Forward

A magnifying glass over a blurred city at night, the cover of Challenger Brand Study 2027 Part I

Challenger Brand Study 2027

Part I: A Look Back to Move Forward

Challenger Brand Study 2027

Part I: A Look Back to Move Forward

Challenger brands play an increasingly important role in reshaping the CPG landscape, capturing an outsized share of category growth and forcing established leaders to rethink how they compete. Across categories, emerging brands are winning with disruptive approaches to meeting evolving consumer needs while legacy players struggle to sustain relevance and growth.

At Seurat, we’ve spent the better part of the last decade studying challengers and the principles fueling their success. Ahead of the 2027 Challenger Brand study coming this January, we’ve looked back to move forward. We revisited brands we’ve profiled to understand what separates those that create initial disruption from those that create enduring growth, often generating enough incremental brand and category value to merit acquisition. What surfaced was a “Challenger Growth Engine”: a set of interconnected principles for creating and sustaining growth.

Seurat Group Challenger Brand Study History, 2015 to 2026: Decade of the Challenger Brand (2015), Challenger Brand Growth Algorithm (2016), Challenger Brand Study (2017), Magic of the Moat (2018), Delighting the Modern Consumer and Honest Company Profile/CEO Q&A (2019), Challenging in an Omni-World and Top-10 Female-Founded Challengers (2020), A Look Back to Look Forward (2021), Gen Z Disruptors (2022), Tillamook Profile: Unlocking Challenger Within and Evolving the Consumer Value Equation (2023), Breaking Through via Cultural Connectivity (2024), Challenger 2.0 (2025), Reimagining and Modernizing Categories (2026)
Seurat Challenger Brands 2019 - 2026: logos of the challenger brands Seurat Group has featured

Of the 85 brands we’ve featured since 2019, 3 in 4 have successfully sustained momentum by activating the Challenger Growth Engine1. While rooted in how emerging Challengers win, these principles offer a powerful model for all CPG brands seeking to reignite growth, strengthen consumer relevance, and uncover new opportunities within and beyond their core business. This paper unpacks the core principles of the Challenger Growth Engine with select case studies of brands that we featured when they were early Challengers.

Looking back across nearly a decade of Challenger brands reveals that success begins with (1) modernizing the value equation, going beyond traditional price, pack, and product benefits to address what consumers truly value and redefining category expectations to establish compelling reasons to choose. Challengers sustain this momentum by (2) turning trial into ritual, building lasting consumer habits by converting trial into repeat purchase and enduring brand preference. With a differentiated value proposition and a highly engaged consumer base, they (3) unlock new waves of growth by addressing emerging consumer needs, expanding into additional occasions and/or pursuing adjacent opportunities with a right to win.

1 Success was determined based on brands’ ability to expand into new categories, occasions, formats or consumer segments, supported by documented growth in revenue, market share, distribution, valuation, or acquisition following that expansion.

Modernize the Value Equation

Consumers continually assess what they get relative to what they give up, encouraging brands to deliver a more compelling balance of benefits and costs. Successful Challengers modernize the value equation in two ways: (1) optimizing the core product offering by prioritizing must-haves over wants to eliminate unnecessary costs and (2) expanding dimensions of value beyond traditional product benefits to address deeper human needs. Brands expand dimensions of value through relevance, aspiration, accessibility, and convenience, addressing evolving functional, emotional, and cultural needs. Chomps addresses both principles by delivering high-quality, all-natural protein without unnecessary ingredients found in traditional meat sticks, such as added sugars, curing agents, and synthetic casings, while providing a convenient, portable snack that makes nutritious eating fit effortlessly into busy lifestyles. By developing a more nuanced understanding of what consumers truly value, Challengers solve tensions, redefine category expectations, and create differentiated reasons to choose their brands, attracting new consumers and giving those who previously sat outside the category reasons to participate.

Turn Trial into Ritual

To give consumers reasons to return, brands must find ways to become a natural part of their everyday lives. This starts by making the brand easy to incorporate into existing routines, removing barriers to use through simplified preparation, improved packaging, or increased availability. Subscriptions, meaningful benefits, and other incentives can further make continued engagement convenient and rewarding. Creating seamless experiences across channels further reduces friction, making the brand easy to access, engage with, and return to. Smalls puts this principle into practice through personalized onboarding quizzes, flexible subscription deliveries, and dedicated customer service that simplify the feeding experience for cat owners. Brands can further strengthen loyalty by building genuine relationships with consumers, creating opportunities for consumers to connect with the brand and one another, and making them feel recognized and appreciated. Fishwife x Whole Foods Market limited-edition tote bag collectionThese relationships also create opportunities to better understand consumers, using behaviors and preferences to anticipate changing needs to continuously improve products, services, and experiences. Fishwife cultivates this connection through playful social media engagement and creative collaborations, including a limited-edition Whole Foods Market tote bag collection that brought the brand into consumers’ everyday routines, turning brand affinity into a visible expression of identity. The collaboration sold over 99% of inventory in its first week, demonstrating the strength of its consumer following. By adapting alongside consumers, brands can deliver increasingly relevant and personalized experiences that strengthen their role in everyday routines, becoming an essential part of consumers’ lives and creating a brand ecosystem that keeps them highly engaged.

Fuel the Perpetual Growth Engine

The Challenger Growth Engine. 1. Modernize the value equation (get consumers in): deliver a more compelling balance of benefits and costs. 2. Turn trial into ritual (keep consumers in): make the brand a natural part of everyday life. 3. Unlock new waves of growth: apply the proven formula to new occasions, adjacent categories and consumer segments. Repeat the formula to fuel ongoing, sustained growth.

Once Challengers have established a differentiated value proposition and turned trial into ritual, they unlock successive waves of growth by extending their model for success across new spaces. Challengers that scale achieve sustainable growth by bringing the principles of modernizing the value equation and deepening consumer relationships into new occasions, adjacent categories, and consumer segments. Rather than simply introducing new products, they identify where their existing strengths can solve new problems or meet different consumer needs. Each expansion builds on what consumers already value about the brand, creating new reasons to engage and broadening its reach. By continually applying these principles, Challengers create a self-reinforcing engine for sustained growth, keeping their brand in perpetual motion.

The following case studies demonstrate how previously featured Challenger brands have successfully activated the Challenger Growth Engine.

Case study: Siete

Siete

Featured:
2024
Valuation:
$1.2B in 2025

Siete was born from the founder’s desire to enjoy beloved foods while navigating dietary restrictions. What began as a homemade family solution evolved into a mission to make culturally meaningful foods accessible to more consumers. The brand introduced grain-free tortillas as an alternative to traditional flour tortillas, allowing consumers avoiding gluten or grains to enjoy familiar Mexican-American foods without compromising on taste, modernizing the value equation by eliminating a longstanding category trade-off. Siete’s proposition extended beyond allergy-friendly alternatives, weaving cultural heritage, family identity, and inclusivity into its brand to expand dimensions of value and create deeper emotional relevance among consumers. Its family-founded mission of bringing more people to the table built genuine relationships rooted in shared values, community, and belonging.

Siete brand celebration of heritage, history and flavorSiete tortilla chips, potato chips, sweet snacks, salsas and seasoningsSiete grain-free tortillas

Siete fueled its perpetual growth engine by extending its values and brand promise both within and beyond traditionally Mexican-American products, unlocking new consumption occasions through tortilla chips, potato chips, and sweet snacks. The brand then carried the same commitment to thoughtfully selected ingredients, cultural heritage, and taste into salsas, sauces, seasonings, and beans, extending its role across everyday meals. By repeatedly applying its principles of expanding value through inclusivity and fostering emotional connection, Siete transformed a solution to a specific dietary need into a broader food platform rooted in Mexican-American heritage, with a proven formula for sustained growth, culminating in its $1.2 billion acquisition by PepsiCo in 2025.


Case study: Graza

Graza

Featured:
2025
Valuation:
$450M - $600M

Graza Frizzle, Sizzle and Drizzle squeeze bottles and Sizzle spray
Frizzle, Sizzle, Drizzle squeeze bottles & Sizzle spray
Graza olive oil potato chips

Premium olive oil has traditionally been associated with specialty cooking and provenance, often accompanied by uncertainty and confusion around quality, usage, and value. Graza entered the category with a goal to make high-quality olive oil more approachable and relevant to everyday cooking. Through playful branding, mess-free squeeze bottles, and varieties differentiated by olive harvest timing and intended use, Graza modernized the value equationGraza Sizzle and Drizzle refill cansSizzle & Drizzle refill cans by going beyond traditional product benefits to deliver greater convenience, ease of use, and a sense of fun to everyday cooking. Beyond attracting initial trial, the brand focused on building habits through specific offerings for distinct consumer jobs, including Sizzle for cooking, Drizzle for finishing, and Frizzle for high-heat cooking, alongside refill formats that encourage repeat purchase. Together, these innovations embedded Graza into consumers’ cooking routines, transforming premium olive oil from an occasional ingredient into a kitchen staple.

Graza mayonnaise and aioliBuilding on this differentiated proposition, Graza fueled its perpetual growth engine by extending its approach to premiumization into adjacent categories. Olive oil potato chips brought ingredient quality and sourcing into snacking, while mayonnaise and aioli carried the brand’s ingredient-first philosophy, approachable branding, and convenient formats into everyday condiments. Across these expansions, Graza continued to modernize the value equation by identifying consumer jobs to be done and building targeted solutions for habitual engagement, demonstrating how a differentiated approach to commoditized categories can unlock opportunities for growth beyond the original category.

We hope that looking back at the lessons behind the Challenger Growth Engine inspires brands of every heritage and size to unlock their Challenger within. To celebrate these principles further, Seurat Group will join Stella Rising for a webinar on December 10. Click here to register!

Stay tuned for Part II of our Challenger Brand Study in January, where we’ll identify the next wave of Challengers poised to disrupt, scale, and reshape their categories by applying new rules of disruption to succeed in an ever-changing landscape.

As always, we would love to hear from you. Let’s discuss how to apply these principles and learn more about any of our Challenger Brand studies.

Please reach out at: info@seuratgroup.com
Challenger Brand Study 2026

Challenger Brand Study 2026

Challenger Brand Study 2026

Challengers who modernize and redefine their categories

Challenger brands are lauded for their disruptive values and their outsized contribution to CPG growth. While many “challenger” brands often play on the fringes, true breakthrough comes from going beyond niche disruption to redefining and modernizing existing categories.

This year’s study focuses on the next wave of challenger brands that are reigniting both consumer relevance and growth within their categories, not just for themselves.

Against a backdrop of stagnating unit growth and rising anti-consumerist sentiment, these brands demonstrate how to drive durable category value creation. They’re infusing new energy and modernity into sleepier categories by leaning into better-for-you ingredients, unlocking new consumption occasions, and leveraging lifestyle-driven branding to deepen consumer connection. In doing so, they’re pulling their categories back into the cultural zeitgeist and bringing new consumers into the fold.

We are excited to highlight 10 challenger brands across a spectrum of disruption: from emerging challengers pushing boundaries to more established modernizers that have already reshaped consumer expectations.

What stands out across these brands is not a single playbook, but a shared orientation in designing for the future of the category, not fenced in by its present.

Challenger Brand Category Impact Spectrum

Sleep or Die: Sleep or Die is jolting the sleep aid category awake with provocative energy and functional credibility in a space that long felt clinical, lifeless, and, well, sleepy. Recognizing that millennials and Gen Z are desperately seeking rest but rejecting the sedative-heavy, side-effect-laden solutions of the past, the brand taps into a cultural shift where younger consumers are embracing wellness rituals but still crave the bold aesthetics of nightlife culture. By pairing credible functional ingredients like melatonin, L-theanine, and GABA with irreverence and design that feels more like a nightlife brand than a pharmacy product, then delivering it in a tab format that feels edgy and unexpected, Sleep or Die transforms the nightly wind-down into something bold and intentional. Sleep or Die is not just refreshing the sleep aid category. It is turning the nightly wind-down into something bold and current, not tired and medicinal. (Source 1 | Source 2 | Source 3) 

Gamsa Foods: Oatmeal is widely viewed as a healthy breakfast staple, but most bowls rely on sugary add-ons to make them appealing, leaving a gap for tasty, convenient, and savory breakfast options. Gamsa Foods recognized an opportunity to modernize without asking consumers to abandon familiar morning habits, introducing savory oatmeal inspired by traditional Korean porridge. Each bowl blends oats with quinoa and rice, layered with bold, umami-forward flavors like sesame, garlic, miso, and seaweed, delivering the warmth and comfort of a home-cooked Korean breakfast in a format ready in minutes. By infusing oatmeal with global flavor and cultural relevance, Gamsa reopens the breakfast category to savory, culturally grounded eating in a space long dominated by sweetness and sameness. (Source 1 | Source 2)

Oddball: Gelatin snacks have long been defined by a single legacy player, beloved for nostalgia but increasingly misaligned with modern expectations around ingredients and wellness. Oddball identified why consumers were quietly walking away. It was not because they stopped loving the jiggly, playful format, but because it no longer felt worth the compromise. By rebuilding jelly snacks with real fruit, plant-based gelling agents, and cleaner ingredients, Oddball gives consumers permission to enjoy a familiar childhood ritual without the artificial baggage. In a world where indulgence increasingly needs permission, Oddball offers a way to keep the fun without the guilt. With growing retail distribution and seed funding fueling expansion, the brand shows how even the most entrenched nostalgia-driven categories can be meaningfully modernized without losing their sense of joy. (Source 1 | Source 2 | Source 3 | Source 4)  

Acid League: The vinegar category has long suffered from low mindshare, treated as a commodity rather than an ingredient worth exploring. Acid League recognized that the category was quietly primed for a renaissance as interest grew in flavor complexity, functional benefits, and more creative uses for everyday pantry staples. By introducing premium, small-batch vinegars with bold, culinary-forward flavor profiles and design that feels curated, the brand repositioned vinegar as something to discover rather than simply stock. It turns vinegar from a dusty bottle in the back of the pantry into a flavor tool people actually want to reach for. As the category expands, Acid League sits squarely within a broader revival of this ancient functional food, unlocking new relevance and new usage occasions along the way. (Source)

Churn: Founded by Chef Michael Tashman, Churn offers flavor-packed, wholesome butters designed to transform any dish into a bold, satisfying moment. From Parmesan and Pepper to the sweet warmth of Maple and Cinnamon, each tub is built to be a consumer’s sous chef, a simple tool that lets anyone confidently, conveniently, and affordably elevate their cooking. The brand wins by activating at the intersection of three emerging consumer trends: demand for convenience, flavor curiosity, and a preference for wholesome ingredients. In an era of burnout and economic uncertainty, Churn gives people a way to feel creative and capable in the kitchen again without more effort. In doing so, it helps turn a basic commodity into an accessible form of everyday indulgence. (Source)

Heyday Canning Co.: Heyday taps into a simple tension: consumers love cans for their practicality, but the food inside has historically been uninspiring. The brand closes that gap by bringing creative flavor combinations and fresh-tasting, high-quality ingredients to a format people already trust. It delivers the cozy, nostalgic comfort of classic canned soups and pantry staples while pairing it with modern recipes and aesthetic packaging that feel genuinely exciting rather than like a compromise. As Heyday gains traction, including its recent launch at Target, it is helping the legacy canned food category evolve its relevance for today’s consumers. In doing so, Heyday is reintroducing an entire generation to canned food as something worth choosing, not just settling for. (Source)

Fishwife: Fishwife is infusing bold flavor and fresh energy into a category that long felt bland and overlooked in the United States. Inspired by the high-flavor tinned fish culture of Spain, the brand taps into growing culinary curiosity and interest in globally inspired foods. By pairing sustainable, ethically sourced seafood with vibrant design and modern flavor profiles, Fishwife transforms tinned fish into an affordable, everyday luxury. The brand leans into charcuterie and “girl dinner” trends, delivering bites that are delicious, nutritious, and picture perfect. Fishwife is not just refreshing tinned fish. It is attracting entirely new consumers and redefining what canned seafood can represent in modern food culture. (Source 1 | Source 2 | Source 3)

Lume: Born from OB-GYN Shannon Klingman’s experience with countless women raising concerns about body odor below the belt, Lume has reshaped expectations in deodorant by leading the charge on whole-body odor care. From traditional sticks and sprays to creams, cleansing washes, and wipes, Lume takes a different approach by acidifying the skin to block odor before it starts, using mandelic acid instead of aluminum or harsher, irritating ingredients. The brand also takes an unapologetic approach to education and destigmatization, openly talking about odor on social media in a way no one else in the category does. In doing so, Lume expands deodorant from a single-use product into a broader personal care category built around whole-body confidence. (Source)

Kevin’s Natural Foods: Kevin’s did not just modernize frozen and refrigerated meals. It permanently changed what consumers and retailers expect from the category. Before Kevin’s, convenience meals were synonymous with compromise: heavy, artificial, and nutritionally suspect. Kevin’s proved that ready-to-heat could be clean, flavorful, and genuinely aspirational. Built on sous-vide preparation and real culinary flavors, the brand unlocked a new consumer truth: busy people no longer accept “good enough” food. Kevin’s explosive, unicorn-level growth forced retailers to re-architect the frozen aisle, making space for premium, chef-driven entrées and catalyzing the “fancy frozen” movement now sweeping the category. The brand’s 2023 acquisition by Mars is not just an exit story. It is evidence that Kevin’s successfully reset the economics and expectations of convenience food, pulling an entire category into a more premium, health-forward future. (Source 1 | Source 2) 

Chomps: Meat snacks carried baggage: perceived as over-processed, nutritionally suspect, and limited to a narrow consumer base. By rebuilding meat sticks with simple ingredients, clear quality credentials (100% grass-fed, Whole30-approved), and elevated packaging, Chomps made meat snacks feel modern, trustworthy, and approachable. The brand even leans into category stigma with self-aware messaging, “all the stick without the ick,” helping disarm skeptics and invite first-time users into the set. Chomps has already shifted the category’s center of gravity. Roughly two-thirds of its consumers were new to meat snacks before discovering the brand, helping establish clean-label protein as the new baseline for what meat snacks should be. Now one of the fastest-growing food brands in the U.S., Chomps is not just benefiting from category momentum. It helped create it. (Source 1 | Source 2)

Implications for All Brands

The challenger brands in this year’s study show how the challenger mindset has evolved. Across categories, these brands are actively reviving familiar categories and redefining what they stand for, and reimagining what they can become.

Even the most established categories can be reignited with the right insight and conviction. Because the strongest challengers do not just grow themselves, they help shape what comes next for the entire shelf.

As always, we would love to hear from you. If you would like more information on any of our challenger brand studies, or want to share a brand of your own, please reach out at info@seuratgroup.com.